Chicken and Leek Plate Pie

Image of trees in autumn colours

The best thing about the onset of autumn is the excuse to return to comfort food and this pie really hits the spot.

I like a pie that has a top and bottom crust, partly because if there’s any left over to enjoy cold, it’s easier to pick up and eat for a picnic supper in front of the fire and something brainless on the telly. But if you’re in a hurry just bung a ready-made pastry lid on it. It’ll taste just as good.

WARNING: If you’re faint-hearted and like your chicken neatly packaged in a polystyrene tray, skip the next few paragraphs.

Our hens went off the lay last winter for nearly five months while still eating their heads off. This is the cost of being seduced by poncey breeds with pretty plumage – I’ll be going back to my faithful, friendly and reliable brown chooks next time.

Image of hen with eggs

The old brown hens were much more productive

So I swore that when Hendini and Nelly stopped laying this year they’d be for the chop. Cue much wailing from our niece who said: “How can you kill them when you’ve given them names?” Easily, is the answer. I’m far too parsimonious to feed them when they’re unproductive. I will, however, spare you the photographs. Except this one.

Image of Hendini the hen

Hendini – no more escape bids

As they’d had plenty of exercise and possessed thighs worthy of an Olympic sprinter, I poached them with lots of veg and herbs until they were tender, then strained the stock and reduced it to intensify the flavour.

You don’t have to go around slaughtering innocent hens to make this dish though. Just buy a good-quality (nameless) chicken and follow the recipe. You can use leftover roast chicken if you prefer: have a look here for a similar recipe that’s a bit quicker to make.

Chicken and Leek Plate Pie

Image of chicken and leek pie

Ingredients to poach the chicken:

1 good-quality oven-ready chicken, about 1.8kg/4lb.

2 carrots, peeled and roughly chopped

1 large onion, peeled and roughly chopped

2 sticks of celery, roughly chopped

A handful of button mushrooms (optional), roughly chopped

A big handful of fresh parsley

2 bay leaves, fresh or dried

8-10 black peppercorns

Small pinch of salt

Image of sliced leeks

For the pie:

The cooked meat picked from the poached chicken

2-3 rashers of streaky bacon

1 medium onion, peeled and chopped

2 fat cloves of garlic

2 medium leeks, cleaned and finely sliced into rings

50g/2 oz fresh mushrooms

A big handful of finely chopped fresh parsley

A knob of butter

2 tbsp plain flour

About 750ml chicken stock, preferably home-made

Salt and freshly-ground black pepper

A dash of double cream

400g/12 oz shortcrust pastry

Image of chicken pastry cutter

Adding insult to injury with the pie decorations


First poach the chicken. Assuming you’re not using an old boiler (stop it!), wipe the chicken and remove any giblets then put it in a deep pan with salted cold water to cover, along with the stock ingredients.

Bring to the boil, then lower the heat and cook gently, covered, for 40 minutes until tender. Remove the chicken and set aside to cool.

Strain the stock and return it to the cleaned pan. Cook over a medium heat until reduced and intensified in flavour. Remove from the heat and set aside to cool, then skim off any fat.

Pre-heat the oven to 200c/400F/Gas Mark 6 and put in a baking sheet to heat up.

Pick the meat from the cooled chicken and cut into bite-sized chunks.

Slice the bacon into thin strips and fry in a large, hot, dry pan until the fat runs and the bacon is starting to crisp. Remove and set aside.

Image of veg cooking

Put the prepared onion and leeks into the hot bacon fat and fry gently until soft. Add the chopped garlic and fry for a few minutes more. Now melt in a knob of butter and throw in the sliced mushrooms and cook for a couple of minutes.

Stir through the flour, mixing well to amalgamate, and cook for a minute or two. Add the chicken stock a little at a time, as in a roux. Put the chicken and bacon back in and cook gently, uncovered, for about 20 minutes until you have a thick, spoonable sauce.

Add a small splash of cream, stir through the chopped parsley, season with salt and pepper to taste and allow to cool. You can prepare it to this point and refrigerate it if you wish.

Roll out the pastry on a floured board and cut two circles, one to fit the base of a lightly greased 9-10″/23-24cm pie plate and one about 2.5 cm/1″ bigger. Line the base and spoon in the cooled pie filling. Dampen the rim of the pie with a little water or beaten egg, then put the lid on, trim and crimp the edges. Use any leftover pastry to decorate the top.

Image of uncooked pie

Cut a cross in the middle to let the steam out and brush with beaten egg. Place in the oven on the heated baking sheet and cook for 30-35 minutes until the crust is crisp and brown and the filling piping hot.

Image of a slice of pie







6 thoughts on “Chicken and Leek Plate Pie

  1. I remember the first time I participated in the tasty demise of a chicken. Hated plucking the damned feathers but it was good in the end. This pie looks fantastic and I’m sure it tasted as good as it looked!

    • I made Him Outdoors do the plucking but I have to say drawing chickens is not my favourite activity. Still, if you’re going to eat meat, I feel you have to be honest about where it comes from. That’s not to say everyone has to go around wilfully slaughtering harmless hens but you get my drift …

  2. What a fitting tribute to an old hen. Absolutely gorgeous pie! I don’t like my chicken “neatly packaged in a polystyrene tray,” yet I do always find myself a bit faint-hearted when ours meet that same end. I know it’s the right thing, but I usually cower in the house. Still, I’ve come a long way from the days when I could eat them only when they reached the stage of good stock.

Leave a Reply